Little Andrew found a lost wallet full of money. In it he discovered the picture of a pretty redhead, probably the owner.
Next morning, Andrea found on her doorstep her lost wallet. Someone must have brought it during the night.
She inspected it; nothing was missing, except for her picture.
boy with a hat 
Again, you keep that slightly creepy, deliciously entertaining edge!
of course he needed the picture for inspiration later. 😉
It was such a pretty picture… You cannot blame him.